FrontPage
Concept Map †
The concept map is graphical representation to allow people to present their conceptual knowledge.
The concept map consists concept words, links, and link labels.
Concept map has been used to capture conceptual change for learners.
It also has been used to compare expert knowledge structure with novices.
We use Cmap to capture searchers’ knowledge structure on search topics.

To understand learning by searching †
- How much do they learn through searching ?
- Using concept maps and Comparing the pre-search map with the post-search map
- How are their learning influenced by factors associated with searching ?
- Comparing the changes in cmaps between search topics and between search scenarios.
Three types of node †

This figure shows the concept map drawn by a participant for the environment topic.
The node enclosed dotted line show the center node. The nodes enclosed red line with the same number show that the participant checked these nodes as having the same meaning..
We divided nodes into three types.
- Nodes that participants identified as having the same meaning in the pre and post search maps were defined as common nodes.
- Nodes that exist only in a pre map were defined as lost nodes.
- Nodes that exist only in a post map were defined as new nodes.
Number of Nodes at Each Distance from the Center Node †
- Number of Nodes at Each Distance from the Center Node
- Distance: number of links from the center node to each node.
- Amount of change: subtracting from the number of nodes at each distance in post-search map to those in pre-search map

To analyze differences in the position of each node, we defined distance in each node.
Distance in each node is measured by the number of links from the center node to each node.
In this figure, these nodes are distance 1 and these nodes are distance 2 and these nodes are distance 3.

Moreover, to clear the differences between scenarios and topics, we calculated the amount of change for each distance from the pre to post-search concept maps by subtracting from the number of nodes at each distance in post-search map to those in pre-search map.
If the number of nodes in distance n in the post-search map is more than those in the pre-search map, amount of change N is positive value. If the number of nodes in distance N in the post-search map is less than those in the pre-search map, amount of change N is negative value.
In these maps, amount of change in each distance is as follows.
references †
- [2012:International conference] Using Concept Map to Evaluate Learning by Searching
- Hitomi Saito, Yuka Egusa, Masao Takaku, Makiko Miwa, Noriko Kando
- In Proceedings of the 34th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society (CogSci2012) Aug 2012 (2012-08)
- [2011:International conference] Evaluation of Interactive Information Access System using Concept Map
- Masaharu Yoshioka, Noriko Kando, Yohei Seki
- In Proceedings of the 4th International Workshop on Evaluating Information Access (EVIA2011) 20-23 Dec 2011 (2011-12)
- [2011:International conference] Changes in Users’ Knowledge Structures Before and After Web Search on a Topic: Analysis Using the Concept Map
- Hitomi Saito, Ryo Nakashima, Yuka Egusa, Masao Takaku, Hitoshi Terai, Makiko Miwa and Noriko Kando
- 74th Annual Meeting of the American Society for Information Science and Technology (Poster) (2011-10)
- [2010:international conference] Connecting Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis of Web Search Process: Analysis Using Search Units
- Hitomi Saito, Masao Takaku, Yuka Egusa, Hitoshi Terai, Makiko Miwa, Noriko Kando
- In Information Retrieval Technology: Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 2010, Volume 6458/2010, 173-182, Proceedings AAIRS 2010 (2010-12)
- doi:10.1007/978-3-642-17187-1_16
- [2010:international conference] Using a Concept Map to Evaluate Exploratory Search